UK Frozen Pensions Case Returns To The European Court Of Human Rights (ECHR) on September 2

No Gravatar

The International Consortium of British Pensioners (ICPB) had decided earlier that they would appeal a negative decision on the Frozen UK Pensions case and move to the 17-judge ECHR Grand Chamber. This appeal will now take place on September 2.

An article in the UK Telegraph outlines the case well. It is titled How saving the pound led to 54 years of injustice.

The real question is whether the appropriate resolution for these Frozen UK Pensions , should be deternined by legality, equity or morality. If it were based on equity or morality, then most observers agree on the outcome. Instead the UK Government has chosen to treat it only as a legal question and so far the answer has been no. Perhaps the ECHR on September 2 will come to a Yes view as the chairman of the earlier ECHR hearing did in his dissenting opinion. Some 500,000 UK pensioners around the world are watching with bated breath.

Other References

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Technorati Tags: , ,

Retirement Planning – Pensions Galore

No Gravatar

Herewith without comment: Glenys and Neil Kinnock have six state pensions – Times Online.

GLENYS KINNOCK, the new minister for Europe, has amassed six publicly funded pensions worth £185,000 per year with her husband Neil, the former leader of the Labour party. They have already received up to £8m of taxpayers’ money in pay and allowances, he as a European commissioner and she as a member of the European parliament.

The pair are already drawing payments from three of their taxpayer-funded pensions. Glenys Kinnock, 64, soon to be elevated to the House of Lords alongside her husband, is collecting a teacher’s pension and from next month is entitled to another from Brussels with an estimated annual value of £48,000.

Lord Kinnock, 67, is receiving one pension as a former MP and a second for his service in Brussels, together worth more than £112,000. Glenys Kinnock is simultaneously drawing a ministerial salary of £83,275. Her job entitles her to a further ministerial pension.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Technorati Tags: , ,

Frozen UK Pensions Good News – The Case Moves To The 17-judge ECHR Grand Chamber

No Gravatar

The Frozen UK Pensions Case concerns the inequity in state pension treatment for some UK pensioners. Whereas half of UK state pensioners living outside the UK have pensions that are exactly the same as those for UK residents, the other half (in Canada, Australia and South Africa and other Commonwealth countries) have pensions that are frozen at the rate that applied at the time they left the UK.  The case continues to progress to what everyone hopes will be an equitable conclusion despite the opposition of the UK government.

In November 2008, although the chairman of the 6-judge Lower Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights stated that he felt the arguments put forward were right, his five colleagues did not agree.  The Consortium believed that the lower chamber’s majority findings were legally flawed, in particular for treating the case as a non-contributory ‘social security’ matter rather than a contributory pension issue. Accordingly the Consortium decided to ask for a referral to the Grand Chamber. 

Tony Bockman, chairman of The International Consortium of British Pensioners (ICBP), has now informed members that a panel of five judges of the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has accepted that the case should be referred to the 17-judge Grand Chamber. Since only ten per cent of applications for referral to the Grand Chamber are successful, this is deemed to be a favorable sign.

The Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) will hear the discrimination case on 2 September 2009.  The legal action is in the hands of London human rights lawyers Timothy Otty QC and Ben Olbourne of 20 Essex Street.  More details on the ECHR hearing can be found on the Pension Parity UK website. The website also provides a great deal of information documenting the facts on this most inequitable situation.

Other Previous Posts

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Technorati Tags: , ,

Pensions Information Google May Not Show You

No Gravatar

Google may know a lot of information about pensions but it may not always show all it knows.  This comes to mind because I happened to stumble on some Electric information from Pensions World, which is not all that visible to search queries.

Take a surf with Robin Ellison through the world wide web and discover pensions at the touch of a button.  There is a lot of pensions law out there. There are plenty of books; increasingly however, electronics are adding a new approach to finding and interpreting the flood of new rules and regulations.

The reason why this is less visible than it should be is that normally it is visible within a framed web site at Pensions World. Wherever you go on the website, the URL never changes in the address field.

Google does acknowledge its problem with Frames.

Google supports frames and iframes to the extent that it can. Frames can cause problems for search engines because they don’t correspond to the conceptual model of the web.

If you use wording such as “This site requires the use of frames,” or “Upgrade your browser,” instead of providing alternate content on your site, then you’ll exclude both search engines and individuals who’ve disabled frames on their browsers.

Another website in the Frozen UK Pensions field that has some good information slightly buried is that for the British Australian Pensioner Association.  Here are some of the web pages that are worth exploring on frozen pensions.

As a footnote for the technically-minded, it should be noted that by mentioning all these extra web pages here, they will now be much more visible in Google.  There are now direct links to them that in Google’s words probably ‘correspond to the conceptual model of the web’.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Technorati Tags: , , , , , ,

UK MPs Gold-plated Pensions Under Serious Review

No Gravatar

When so many, and in particular pensioners, are suffering world-wide in the global financial crisis, it is almost unbelievable to see the UK Telegraph’s story Gordon Brown to scrap final salary pensions for MPs.

Gold-plated final salary pensions for MPs could be scrapped, under plans put forward by Gordon Brown.  The Prime Minister has called for an investigation into how MPs’ retirements are funded because he fears they are becoming too expensive for the taxpayer.  MPs are still able to retire with large, taxpayer-funded, pension pots.

The move by Mr Brown could eventually allow politicians to propose scrapping all public-sector final salary schemes, currently enjoyed by millions including civil servants, council employees and health workers.  The current total liability of public-sector pensions to the taxpayer is officially estimated at £650 billion, but the Government has been unable to look at reforming the system while MPs still enjoy the same benefits.

If you are unaware of this situation, you may wish to read the full article and then consider which of the following best describes your reaction on reading this:

  • This just cannot be true. It must be an early April Fool’s item.
  • How can a Labour government not have canned this privileged pensions boondoggle years ago?
  • Why did Tony Blair not refuse his additional grace-and-favour pension (possibly over £64,000 a year) as Gordon Brown has done?
  • Why does it need to be studied?
  • What about all those UK pensioners who live in poverty?

Perhaps you have some other reaction to these UK MPs Gold-plated Pensions.  If so, please add a comment and tell us all what you think.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Yes, Yes Minister, Please, Please

No Gravatar

yesminister

Some  have pointed to the link between the global financial crisis and a general acceptance of corruption at high levels.  In that light, today’s item from the UK Daily Mail is a real embarrassment for the UK politicians.  It suggests that Extraordinary freebies are enjoyed by Britain’s mandarins.

Extraordinary details of the lavish hospitality enjoyed by top civil servants have been exposed.  Senior mandarins were wined and dined by blue-chip companies and treated to days at the races, nights at the opera and tickets to major sporting events.  Sir Brian Bender, one of the highest-ranking men in Whitehall, accepted invitations to 52 events  -  an average of one a week.

Remember that the same newspaper at the end of January was headlining the bonuses that Cabinet civil servants had received, so it would not appear that they really need the freebies.

Cabinet Office mandarins last year pocketed almost £ 1million in bonuses, it has emerged.  The senior civil servants received an average bonus of almost £9,300 each last year.  A total of 105 payouts were given at a cost to the taxpayer of £972,500.  The scale of the Whitehall bonus culture was met with dismay by campaigners, at a time when many workers fear losing their jobs in the recession.

We are living through extraordinary times and certainly it is not the time for business as usual.  Equally one would hope that we can get away from government as usual if this is the way it has been conducted.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

Openness In Government – Barack Obama

No Gravatar

This is a somewhat ironic follow-up to the earlier rant about Gordon Brown’s wish to keep embarrassing UK government activities secret.

Actions speak louder than words.  On his very first packed full day in office, Barak Obama has pledged an era of openness.   He has promised a transparent government and said he would change the way the federal government interprets the freedom of information act.

He said he was directing agencies that vet requests for information to err on the side of making information public — not to look for reasons to legally withhold it — an alteration to the traditional standard of evaluation.

Just because a government agency has the legal power to keep information private does not mean that it should, Obama said. Reporters and public-interest groups often make use of the law to explore how and why government decisions were made; they are often stymied as agencies claim legal exemptions to the law.

To achieve this transparency, he promised to apply the very best technology.

Obama’s administration will utilize cutting-edge technologies to give Americans access to his administration’s records and he will likely appoint a chief technology officer who will ensure that government and all its agencies have the right infrastructure policies and services for the 21st century.

Among Obama’s proposals are the creation of internet databases for lobbying reports, ethics records and campaign finance filings as well as a “contracts and influence” database to track federal contractors’ spending and lobby efforts.

One hopes that other national leaders will follow Obama’s lead.  Gordon Brown has backed off his threat to keep the MPs expenses data secret, which would have been voted on tomorrow.  Given the timing it would look as though the Facebook hornet’s nest (now at 8,400 members at the time of writing) that developed had more to do with the change of heart than a wish to emulate the US president.

One hopes the same spirit of openness begins to be more apparent in Canada than is the current norm.  However it is somewhat disheartening to see that the current version of the freedom of information legislation website has only an outdated copy of the legislation available.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Technorati Tags: , ,

Gordon Brown, UK Prime Minister, Old World. Barack Obama, New World.

No Gravatar

What a glorious day occurred yesterday for the whole world with the inauguration of Barak Obama as the new US president.  Now we must all pick up the message, Yes We Can.  That means facing up to reality.

After a whirlwind of galas surrounding his inauguration, Barack Obama begins his first full day as U.S. president Wednesday with a full plate of reality staring him in the face.

Gordon Brown, the UK prime minister says that he sees this as a new chapter
in both American history and the world’s history.  However others have commented before that Prime Minister Gordon Brown is out of touch.

If you will permit a short rant, I note that today’s word in my Forgotten English calendar is mumbudget.  That is an expression denoting secrecy as well as silence.  It seems to be a word beloved by Gordon Brown.

The Times headline today is Gordon Brown backs moved to block full publication of MPs expenses.

Gordon Brown has imposed a three-line whip to force a move to block full publication of MPs’ expenses through the Commons.  Labour MPs could face sanctions if they rebel in tomorrow’s vote on an amendment to the Freedom of Information Act that would exempt MPs from disclosing exactly how they have been spending their annual £22,000 second-home allowance.

The Guardian had already pointed out that the move to make MPs exempt from publishing expenses will antagonize a large number of people.

The move next week will allow parliament to nullify all the long-fought victories by campaigners and journalists to force MPs to publish details of all their individual receipts for their second homes, including details of what they spent on furnishings, maintenance, rent, mortgage payments, staffing, travel, office staffing and equipment.

Public opposition is growing against the move.  At the time of writing this, almost 7,500 people have signed a Facebook campaign led by mySociety.  mySociety runs the “theyworkfor-you” website, that urges MPs not to push through the change.

What a stark comparison.  Gordon Brown in the Old World.  Barak Obama in the New World.  Thankfully the Internet forces openness and makes ever truer those words of Abraham Lincoln at Gettysburg: a government of the people, by the people, for the people.  Please smell the coffee, Mr. Brown.

STOP PRESS: Gordon Brown withdraws plan to keep details of MPs’ expenses secret:
Surprise announcement follows the collapse overnight of a bipartisan agreement between the prime minister and David Cameron

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

UK Pensioners In Poverty

No Gravatar

100 years after first state pension – and 2.5m older people still live in poverty. That is the headline in the latest issue of the Mature Times.    If you are unfamiliar with the Mature Times,  it is well worth a read.  For example there is a Guide To Retirement available on the website.

The figures it quotes on pensioner poverty are most distressing.

In 2007/8 the number of pensioners living below the official poverty line of £151 a week (60% of median population income before housing costs) rose by 300,000 to 2.5m.

Between 1997 and 2006, the number of people living in severe poverty – defined as living on less than 40% of median population income – increased by 600,000. The poorest quarter of pensioner households saw their incomes rise by less than 1% last year, well below inflation. The poorest single pensioners saw their real incomes drop by 4%.

About two thirds of those pensioners living in poverty are women.

Joe Harris, National Pensioners Convention general secretary is quoted as follow:

We owe the original pension pioneers a great debt of gratitude, but they would be turning in their graves if they knew that after 100 years, 1 in 4 pensioners
was still living in poverty. In fact, today’s state pension is worth even less in relation to average wages than it was in 1908, and next year’s increase in the state pension will be a measly £4.55 a week – at a time when millions of older people will be faced with the unenviable dilemma of trying to heat their homes or eat properly.

The National Pensioners Convention (NPC) and over 15 individual trade unions in October 2008 joined together to call for a higher basic state pension for the over 60s of today and tomorrow.

They stressed that a decent state pension is an issue not just for today’s pensioners, but for future generations as well. This point has taken on extra significance given the recent financial crisis and the weakness of private pensions which have recently lost £250bn in value – adversely affecting up to 5m people who are about to retire.

For decades, the policy of successive governments has been to rely on means-tested benefits for existing pensioners and good occupational pension schemes for future generations, as a way of avoiding paying a decent state pension. But this approach is unravelling: means-testing remains unpopular and ineffective at getting money to the poorest, and many decent company pensions are being replaced by insecure money-purchase schemes. Billions of pounds have been wiped off private pension funds in recent weeks – and up to nine million workers now face an insecure retirement.

Unfortunately the UK Labour government seems unwilling to address this issue. The opposition has been more vocal.

Jenny Willott, Liberal Democrat Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary, spoke out on Pensioner Poverty during a Parliamentary debate on 4th June. She attacked the Government’s treatment of pensioners. Ms Willott called for the immediate restoration of the link between pensions and earnings.

The Conservatives proclaimed that Pensioners are to lose nearly £100.

Within the EU only pensioners in Cyprus, Spain and Latvia are more likely to fall into poverty than in the UK. By official measures there are now some 2.5 million pensioners in the UK living in poverty.

Labour’s increased use of complex means testing of pensioners has resulted in reduced take-up of benefits. Between 1.2 and 1.8 million pensioners in the UK failed to take up their entitlement of pension credit last year. Up to 1.2 million of those were living in poverty.

This Government is tired, weak and hurting the most vulnerable people in the country with its incoherent and counter-productive policies.

Unfortunately pensioners in poverty do not have the powerful lobbyists that other sectors of the economy have. It is critical that we all speak up for them.

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Some Frozen UK State Pensioners Get Weather Pay-Outs

No Gravatar

The BBC tells us that Millions to get weather pay-outs

Millions of pensioners and vulnerable people around the UK have become eligible for cold weather payments. The £25-a-week assistance is triggered when an area’s average temperature falls or is forecast to fall to 0C or below for seven consecutive days.  Forecasts for the London area mean 600,000 people are eligible for fuel help for the first time in a decade.

The increased cold weather payments are one part of a package of measures announced by the UK Government this winter.  This year’s Christmas bonus for pensioners and disabled people, which will be paid between January and March, has increased from £10 to £70.  An extra £575m has been spent on winter fuel payments, with £250 for those in households with someone aged 60 or over, and £400 for those with someone aged 80 plus.

These winter fuel payments are also paid to UK State pensioners who have emigrated to those countries where state pensions are indexed with inflation..  Those who have emigrated to places such as Australia or Canada do not receive these extra payments, nor of course are their pensions indexed with inflation. 

Technorati Tags: ,

Search the Internet for related articles:
Loading